When buying or selling a business, a crucial decision to make is whether to use an asset purchase agreement (APA) or sell the entity shares (for a corporation) or membership interests (for an LLC). Both options have distinct advantages and considerations that must be carefully evaluated. At Afsar Law Group, APC, we understand the importance of making the right choice to protect your interests. The following are key pros and cons to each approach.

Asset Purchase Agreement (APA):

An Asset Purchase Agreement involves the transfer of specific assets and liabilities from the seller to the buyer. Here are three pros and cons for utilizing an Asset Purchase Agreement;

Pros:

• Flexibility in Selecting Assets and Liabilities:
  • Buyer selects which assets and liabilities they want to acquire, providing flexibility to cherry-pick the most desirable aspects of the business. This allows buyers to mitigate risks and only assume those liabilities they are comfortable with.

• Protection from Unknown Liabilities:
  • When purchasing assets through an Asset Purchase Agreement, the buyer typically does not inherit the seller’s existing liabilities unless expressly assumed. This can provide protection against potential undisclosed or future liabilities that may exist within the selling entity.

• Favorable Tax Treatment:
  • An Asset Purchase Agreement can offer potential tax benefits. By allocating the purchase price among the acquired assets, the buyer may be able to benefit from stepped-up tax basis, resulting in higher tax deductions for depreciation and amortization in the future. Please check with your tax professional as Afsar Law Group, APC, provides no tax advice.

Cons:

• Contracts and Permits Transfer:
  • Transferring contracts, permits, licenses, and other agreements to the buyer can be more complex with an Asset Purchase Agreement. Some contracts may require consent from third parties, and the transfer process may involve renegotiations or potential termination of existing agreements.

• Potential Customer or Supplier Disruption:
  • Customers and suppliers may view an Asset Purchase Agreement as a change in ownership, potentially causing concerns or disrupting existing business relationships. This disruption may require additional efforts to maintain continuity and reassure stakeholders.

• Potential Entity Formation Challenges:
  • If the buyer intends to operate the acquired business as a separate legal entity, using an Asset Purchase Agreement may require additional legal steps, such as forming a new entity or merging the acquired assets into an existing entity. This can involve additional time, cost, and legal complexities.

Entity Share/Membership Sale:

A corporate share or limited liability company membership sale involves the transfer of ownership in the entity itself. Here are three pros and cons to consider:

Pros:

• Simplicity of Transfer
  • Selling entity shares or membership interests is often a more simple transaction since it involves transferring ownership in the existing legal entity. This may save time and effort compared to transferring individual assets.

• Continuity and Existing Relationships
  • By purchasing entity shares or membership interests, the buyer can maintain existing contracts, licenses, permits, and business relationships, preserving the continuity of operations. This can be beneficial, especially if customer and supplier relationships are critical to the business’s success.

• Potential Tax Benefits:
  • A share or membership sale may provide certain tax advantages, such as the potential for capital gains treatment or the availability of favorable tax elections, which can result in reduced tax liabilities for the seller.

Cons:

• Inherited Liabilities:
  • When purchasing entity shares or membership interests, the buyer should expect to assume all existing liabilities, including undisclosed or contingent liabilities. Due diligence becomes crucial to uncover any potential risks associated with the entity.

• Limited Asset Selection
  • Buyers acquiring entity shares or membership interests generally do not have the flexibility to select specific assets or liabilities. They acquire the entire business entity, including its assets and liabilities as a package deal

• Potential Disputes with Minority Owners
  • In cases where the selling entity has multiple owners, a share or membership sale may involve complexities related to the consent and agreement of all owners. Minority owners may have rights that need to be considered and potentially negotiated, which can add complications to the sale process.

 

Deciding whether to use an Asset Purchase Agreement or sell entity shares or membership interests requires careful evaluation of your specific circumstances and objectives. Consulting with Afsar Law Group, APC, is a crucial step to ensuring you make the right choice. Our office is provides personalized guidance, can help you navigate the complexities of the transaction, and will protect your interests throughout the process. Contact our office in Palm Desert, California, to discuss your business sale goals and receive high-quality legal assistance tailored to your needs.

Back To Business Law